Get in touch with us at RitasBakeshopLLC@gmail.com
Menu
Cakes, Cookies, Pies, & More
Special Occasion Cakes
Indulge in our delectable treats, freshly baked with love and care. Our cakes are perfect for any celebration or simply to satisfy your sweet cravings. Explore our wide range of flavors and designs.
Something for Everyone
We offer a variety of pastries, bakes, and cookies to sweeten your daily moments. Personalize your orders with special messages or designs to make every bite memorable.
Handcrafted
At Rita’s Bakeshop, we focus on quality and flavor in every creation. Each pastry is made with care to bring you a delicious experience you’ll remember.
Small Business
Personal Care
Enjoy the experience of Rita's bakeshop as a small business who cares about our customers and community. We are looking forward to continuing our baking for you!
Dessert Table of Contents
Looking for something specific in our menu? Check out our Dessert Table of Contents for each section of our Menu!
Click on the picture of each section title for a quick travel to your desired menu section.
Allergens & Refrigeration
ATTENTION: SPECIALTY FILLINGS AND CREAM CHEESE ICING ARE PERISHABLE AND MUST BE REFRIGERATED UNTIL DISPLAY TIME. PLEASE CONSIDER REFRIGERATOR SPACE WHEN ORDERING.
ALLERGIES: PLEASE ALERT US TO ANY KNOWN ALLERGIES. WE WILL MAKE NOTE OF IT ON ORDER FORM AND USE THE UTMOST CARE IN AVOIDING NOTED ALLERGEN. HOWEVER, WE CANNOT, IN ANY WAY, 100% GUARANTEE AN ALLERGEN FREE PRODUCT.
WE USE MANY ALLERGENS IN OUR BAKESHOP.
SUCH AS COCONUT, TREE NUTS, PEANUTS, SOY, WHEAT, MILK, SPICES, FOOD DYES, ETC.
WE ALSO USE SHARED EQUIPMENT, TOOLS, ETC.
Round Cakes
6" Round Cake
Serves up to 5 (single layer) or 10 (double layer)
Ideal for the classic "Smash Cake"
Single Layer: Starting at $16+
Double Layer: Starting at $32+
8" Round
Serves up to 8 (single layer) or 16 (double layer)
Single Layer: Starting at $22+
Double Layer: Starting at $44+
9" Round
Serves up to 12 (single layer) or 24 (double layer)
Single Layer: Starting at $28+
Double Layer: Starting at $56+
10" Round
Serves up to 15 (single layer) or 30 (double layer)
Single Layer: Starting at $34+
Double Layer: Starting at $68+
12" Round
Serves up to 22 (single layer) or 44 (double layer)
Single Layer: Starting at $50+
Double Layer: Starting at $100+
Sheet Cakes
7" x 11" Sheet
Serves up to 15
Starting at $35+
Quarter Sheet (9" x 13")
Serves up to 24
Starting at $46+
11" x 15" Sheet
Serves up to 40
Starting at $65+
Half Sheet (12" x 18")
Serves up to 54
Starting at $80+
15" x 22" Sheet
Serves up to 80
Starting at $125+
Full Sheet (24" x 18")
Serves up to 100
Starting at $150+
- Custom Cakes -
Classic Décor
Flowers
Balloons
Based with Borders
*Included in Price
Custom Designs
Custom of your choice
Pictures of Ideas
Pictures of Similar Designs
Edible Images
*Additional Charges
- Designs -
Unique Shapes
Shaped Cakes and Cupcake Cakes!
• Custom Options: Shaped cake on sheet cake
• Serving Size: 12–15 guests, or more!
• Price: $48–$60
(basic flavors, white icing)
• Cupcake Cakes: starting at $2.50 each with classic homemade vanilla icing
Popular Shapes
Animals
Monkey, Lion, Puppy, Cat, Fish, Teddy Bear, Panda, Turkey, Deer, 3D Lamb, 3D Teddy Bear, 3D Ducky
Party
Guitar, Topsy-Turvy Tier Cake, Daisy Flower
Transportation
Hot Air Balloon, Motorcycle, 3D Car, 70’s Sports Car, Pirate Ship
Popular Shapes
Blessed/Baby
Baby Block (flat/cubed), Cross, Bells, Bible (open/closed)
Sports
Football, Helmet, Golf Bag, Basketball, Baseball, Horseshoe, Bowling, Soccer
Holiday
Flags, Bunny, Easter Egg, Hearts, Pumpkins, Witch, Christmas Tree, Santa, Clovers
Cake Flavors
Standard Cake Flavors
Vanilla
Yellow Vanilla
Chocolate
Marble
Banana
Signature Cake Flavors
Red Velvet
Strawberry
Lemon
Chocolate Chip
Premium Cake Flavors
Coconut
Pound
Tie-Dye Colored
Funfetti
Carrot
*Prices Vary based on Cake Size & Flavor
Icings & Fillings
Standard Icing Flavors
Homemade Vanilla Icing
Signature
Buttercream
Chocolate
Whipped
Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter
Premium Fillings
Chocolate Ganache
Strawberry Jam
Bavarian Cream
Raspberry
Chocolate Cream
Banana Cream
Coconut Cream
Chocolate Chip Cannoli Cream
*1.5x cost
Sliced Fresh Strawberries in Glaze
*1.5x cost
*Prices Vary based on Cake Size & Flavor
- Flavors & Icings -
- Cupcakes -
Standard size cupcakes - Standard flavor with regular homemade vanilla icing (option of sprinkles) $2 each
Specialty Cupcakes start at $ 2.50 each
Individually decorated cupcakes start at $3 each
Cupcake rings and picks start at 40¢ each
Specialty Cakes
Peanut Butter Torte
Four layers of chocolate cake with peanut butter icing, finished with a ganache drip.
Ganache Torte
Four layers of chocolate cake with ganache icing, topped with chocolate curls.
Strawberry Dream
Three layers of yellow cake filled with strawberry jam, iced with cream cheese, and drizzled with strawberry glaze.
Raspberry Dream
Three layers of yellow cake filled with raspberry jam, iced with cream cheese, and drizzled with raspberry glaze.
Banana Dream
Three layers of banana cake iced in cream cheese and topped with white chocolate curls and bordered with walnuts.
Coconut Cream
Three layers of vanilla cake filled with coconut cream, iced in our homemade vanilla icing, and coated in coconut shreds.
Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla pound cake with whip topping and freshly sliced strawberries coated in glaze.
Black Forest Torte
Three layers of German chocolate cake brushed with cherry liqueur, filled with cherry, frosted in whipped icing and topped with chocolate curls and maraschino cherries.
Cannoli Cake
Three layers of white cake filled with choc chip cannoli filling, frosted in whip cream. The cake is topped with whip swirls, ganache drizzle, choc chips, three mini cannoli, and a cannoli shell crumble.
German Choc Cake
Three layers German choc cake with butterscotch pecan coconut homemade icing.
Carrot Cake
Two thick layers of lightly spiced carrot cake chocked full of raisins walnuts and pineapple with cream cheese icing.
Chocolate Sin
Rich chocolate cake infused into a dense fudgy truffle with ganache icing.
- Specialty Cakes & Cupcakes -
Specialty Cupcakes
Banana Dream
Banana cake with cream cheese icing, topped with white chocolate curls and walnuts.
Banana Peanut Butter
Banana cake filled with peanut butter icing, topped with buttercream icing, banana chips, and peanuts.
Black Bottoms
Dark chocolate cake baked with chocolate chip cheesecake.
Black Forest
German Chocolate cake with cherry filling, whip icing, topped with chocolate curls and cherry.
Boston Cream
Yellow cake filled with Bavarian, topped with fudge éclair icing and sprinkles.
Carrot
Carrot cake with cream cheese icing and topped with walnuts.
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate chip cake with ganache filling, buttercream icing, and topped with mini chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chip Cannoli
Chocolate chip cake with cannoli filling, whip icing, and topped with ganache drizzle and cannoli shell pieces.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate cake with chocolate pastry cream filling, peanut butter icing, and topped with chocolate curls.
Coconut Cream
White cake with coconut cream filling, regular icing, topped with toasted coconut.
Funfetti
White cake funfetti cupcakes with rainbow sprinkles whip filling, whip icing, and topped with sprinkles.
Fresh Strawberry
White cake with fresh strawberry glaze filling, whip icing, topped with a strawberry.
German Chocolate
German chocolate cake with butterscotch pecan coconut icing.
Lemon
Lemon cake with cream cheese icing, topped with yellow sprinkles.
Specialty Cupcakes
Lemon Blueberry
Lemon cake with blueberry filling, lemon flavored whip, topped with fresh blueberry.
Raspberry Dream
Yellow cake with raspberry filling, cream cheese icing, and topped with raspberry drizzle.
Red Velvet
Red velvet cake with cream cheese icing, topped with chocolate sprinkles.
Strawberry
Strawberry cake with strawberry jam filling, whip icing.
Strawberry Dream
Yellow cake with strawberry jam filling, cream cheese icing, and topped with strawberry drizzle.
TandyCake
White cake with peanut butter filling, fudge icing, and topped with crushed peanuts.
Triple Chocolate
Chocolate cake with ganache filling, chocolate icing, topped with chocolate curls and cherry.
Chocolate Chip
$9/dozen
Cutouts (sugared only)
$16/dozen
Cutouts with Royal Icing
starting at $34/dozen
(price varies by size, design, and color)
Coconut Macaroons
$8.50/dozen
Double Chocolate Chip
$9/dozen
Oatmeal Raisin
$9/dozen
Peanut Butter (flat)
$9/dozen
Peanut Butter Kiss
$9 (9 count)
Raisin Filled
$12/dozen
Raspberry Filled
$9.50/dozen
Ricotta (Iced or Chocolate Chip)
$11/dozen
Sour Cream, Iced with Sprinkles
$10/dozen
Sour Cream, Iced with Coconut
$11/dozen
White Chocolate Macadamia
$9.50/dozen
JUMBO Chocolate Chunk
$3 each
JUMBO Reese’s PB Cookie
$3 each
Cookie Trays - Baker's Assortment
(For Holiday cookie tray assortments, flavors, and prices, see holiday menu)
Cookie Jars
3 dozen medium sized cookies
$34
6 dozen medium sized cookies
$68
9 dozen medium sized cookies
$100
- Cookies -
- Single Serving Pastries -
Éclair – $4
Pâte à choux pastry filled with Bavarian cream, frosted with chocolate fudge icing, and topped with colorful sprinkles.
Lemon Bar – $3
Buttery short pastry crust baked with a zesty lemon topping and dusted with powdered sugar.
*Available May through August.
Chocolate Chip Cannoli – $4
Crispy shell with a hint of cinnamon, filled with chocolate chip ricotta cream and finished with a chocolate drizzle.
Scone – $3.50
Flavors include Blueberry, Raspberry White Chocolate, Raisin, Chocolate Chunk, Cranberry Orange, or Apple Cinnamon.
Brownie – $2.75
Rich chocolate brownie available plain, iced (with or without sprinkles), or with walnuts.
Crème Puff – $4
Pâte à choux pastry filled with your choice of Bavarian cream topped with whipped cream and powdered sugar, or rich chocolate cream topped with chocolate whip and ganache drizzle.
Filled Coconut Long John – $2.75
⭐ A Best Seller!
Yeast-raised donut filled with white angel crème, topped with homemade vanilla icing, and dipped in toasted coconut.
Custom options available (no filling, no coconut, etc.).
Brownie Sundae – $4
Rich chocolate walnut brownie topped with whipped cream, ganache drizzle, sprinkles, walnuts, and a maraschino cherry.
Tandy Cake
4-pack – $6 • 8-pack – $12 • Full pan – $24
Vanilla sponge cake topped with a layer of peanut butter and dark/milk chocolate.
💛 A customer favorite!
Sticky Buns – 7 per pack
Plain – $8.50 • Raisin – $9.50 • Walnut – $10 • White Iced – $10 • Peanut Butter Iced – $10
Cheesecup – $4.25
Mini cheesecakes available plain or topped with raspberry, strawberry, cherry, blueberry, or chocolate chip.
Seasonal flavors available.
Whoopie Pie – $2.75
Available in Chocolate, Banana, or Red Velvet with vanilla filling.
Pumpkin available seasonally.
- Mini Bite Sized Pastries and Trays -
Please let us know if you'd like them boxed or arranged on a tray. Trays are an additional charge. Great for parties, a treat for the office or a little afternoon pick-me-up!
Mini Chocolate Chip Cannoli
Crispy shell with hint of cinnamon, chocolate chip ricotta filling, drizzled with chocolate
$16 per dozen
Mini Cheesecake
Raspberry, strawberry, cherry, or blueberry topped; plain or chocolate chip
$12 per dozen
Mini Brownie Bites
Plain, iced with or without sprinkles, or caramelized
$10 per dozen / $45 for 48ct tray
Mini Brownie Sundaes
Rich chocolate brownies topped with whip, ganache drizzle, sprinkles, walnuts, and a maraschino cherry
$15 per dozen
Mini Crème Puffs
Pastry shell filled with vanilla cream and dusted with powdered sugar
$10 per dozen
Mini Mousse Cups
Edible chocolate cups filled with creamy chocolate mousse
$15 per dozen
Mini Tandy-Cake
Vanilla sponge cake with peanut butter layer and hardened chocolate on top
$10 per dozen / $45 for 48ct tray
Mini Pastry Assortment Tray
Brownie sundae, cannoli, cheesecake, tartlets, crème puffs, éclairs, and mousse cups
$35 for 28ct, $70 for 56ct
Mini Cupcakes
Basic flavor with white icing and sprinkles (2 dozen minimum)
$10 per dozen
Mini Specialty Iced Cupcakes
Buttercream, cream cheese, whip, peanut butter, or chocolate icing (2 dozen minimum, 1 dozen per flavor)
$12 per dozen
Mini Eclairs
Pastry shell filled with cream, frosted with chocolate fudge icing, and topped with sprinkles
$12 per dozen
Mini Fruit Tarts
Short pastry crust with fruit filling and cream cheese icing; flavors include blueberry, cherry, strawberry, and raspberry
$12 per dozen
Mini Lemon Bar Bites
Short pastry crust with tangy lemon topping, dusted with powdered sugar
$10 per dozen
Mini Scones
Blueberry, raspberry-white chocolate, raisin, chocolate chunk, cranberry-orange, and apple
$1.85 each, sold by even flavor amounts
Mini Whoopie Pies
Chocolate, banana, red velvet, or pumpkin with vanilla filling
$16 per dozen (one flavor per dozen)
Apple Double Crust or Crumb
$26
Blueberry Double Crust or Crumb
$24
Cherry Double Crust or Crumb
$24
Fresh Strawberry
$26/ $28 Sept to March
*Subject to availability of nice berries
& the market price.
Pumpkin
(with or without whip)
$25
*Fall to Christmas only
Coconut Custard
$24
Peanut Butter Cream in a Chocolate Cookie Crust
$26
Chocolate Cream
$26
Banana Cream
$26
Coconut Cream
$26
Lemon Meringue
$26
- Pies -
Elegant Wedding Cakes
At Rita's Bakeshop, we specialize in creating timeless and elegant wedding cakes that serve as the centerpiece of your special day. Choose from a variety of flavors, fillings, and customizable decorations to create a cake as unforgettable as your love story.
Dessert Tables & Trays
Enhance your wedding celebration with a custom dessert table featuring an array of sweets like cupcakes, brownies, cookies, éclairs, and fruit tarts. Our dessert tables offer a delicious and visually beautiful way to treat your guests.
Click Here for More!